BEING YAHWEH
THE SIMILARITY OF "YAHWEH" TO "JOV-"
IS GOD 'BEING' AFTER ALL?
J. F. GANNON
|
INFORMATIVE TEXT HERE |
The similarity of "Yahweh" to "Jov-"
J. F. Gannon Is God 'Being' After All?
J. F. Gannon observes:
The similarity of "Yahweh" to "Jov-"
is most likely to be fortuitous. But the
similarity is such that it must have attracted
speculation earlier. I'm betting someone
knows. Here is the little I know. Flavius
Josephus is the fellow most likely to have
made the connection, a Ioudaios writing in
Rome for a Roman audience and stressing parallels
between things Roman and Judean. I have often
wondered about this, and have really, really
wished that he had made the connection. But
he does not. When he comes to the part of
his narrative that parallels Exod. 3, where
Moses asks God's name, he becomes more reserved
than the Bible itself: "And God revealed
to him His name, which had not previously
come to men, and about which I am not permitted
to speak" (AJ 2.276).
This is, incidentally, one of the clearest
early indicators of the traditional rabbinic
refusal to pronounce the divine name. NB:
what one reads instead of the written name
YHWH is of course ADONai -- another tantalizing
one for parallel-seekers. People who did
find some resonances, arguably, were those
who composed the spells on the magical papyri,
which frequently use forms of the name: Yahu,
etc., no doubt surviving in today's popular
ISP "Yahoo". I'm kidding.
Someone mentioned the biblical etymology
of "being" for YHWH, and that is
a much better prospect. It was common among
Greek-speaking Judeans to connect their God
with ZEUS by a Stoic-philosophical analogy:
both names refer to ultimate Being, Nature,
Reason, etc. This is best accomplished with
the accusative form of the name, ZHNA, for
obvious reasons.
See for example Josephus, AJ 12.22, where
the Greek Aristeas allegedly says to King
Ptolemy II, "Both they and we worship
the God who created the universe, whom we
call by the appropriate term ZHNA, giving
Him that name from the fact that He breathes
life (ZHN) into all creatures." In the
so-called Letter of Aristeas itself (3rd
to 1st cent. BC; sect. 16), both ZEUS (ZHNA)
and DIOS (DIA) are connected with life-giving
(ZWOPOIEW), connecting the Judean and Greek
Gods. The same point is suggested by the
Greco-Jewish writer Aristobulus, 2nd cent.
BC, preserved in Eusebius, Praep. Evang.
13.12.7. If Dios, then Iove too, I guess.
|