Copyright © 2010 Jud Evans. Permission granted
to distribute in any medium, commercial
or non-commercial, provided
author attribution and copyright
notices remain intact.
| Physicalising the Mind |
The Need For A New Nomenclature To Replace
The Current Non-Scientific
Reificative Terms Used In Neurological And
Computer Terminology. |
| Some Sample Suggested Replacements Include |
| REIFICATION |
NEW COMBINATION |
THE NEOLOGISM |
| matter |
matter + energy |
matergy |
| sense |
sense + energy |
sensergy |
| data |
data + energy |
datergy |
The terms matter, sense, data, experience/experiencing
and action/activity are useful abstractive
fictions but simply do not exist. Experience
is not a brain activity it IS the brain. Whilst we can do our best with
some success to describe our experiences
(such as tasting salt or sugar) we cannot
identify what experience IS because from
a physicalist POV - what does not exist cannot
be described. There is no duality involved.
What exists is a meaty stimulated and responsive
calculator, which reacts to the internal
and external stimuli in a manner of which
the precise method is not yet totally understood.
The crude notions of there being a mind in there somewhere is acting as an obstacle and financial burden
to serious research, and millions of dollars
are being squandered in a fruitless search
for something which represents the ancient
beliefs of primitive man
All organisms respond to stimuli. Excited
by the light/warmth a leaf turns towards
the sun. When a plant turns towards a light
source it is known as phototropism. But that
does not automatically instantiate phototropism
as an existing dualistic accompaniment of
the phototropic vegetable material. Touch
certain plants and they automatically withdraw
or curl up. That does not mean that some
primitive spook called a curler or curling or a withdrawer or withdrawing can be found in the plant. (compare Heidegger
looked at a leaf and searching for the is of its greenness. In the most notorious confession in philosophy
finally admitted that he did not understand
the meaning of the Be-word is. [1] (Heidegger.Grundbegriffe.Basic Concepts)
For the same reason when neurosurgeons peer
inside the exposed brain looking for a soul or a mind or consciousness or other primitive
stupidities like qualia, etc. they will never
find anything.
Such sun-seeking traits have evolved in plants
over thousands of years. Growing towards
a light source that beneficially changes
the photosynthesising matergic entity, improves
the survival rate of the plant. The human
brain has developed in a similar way. Whilst
the greatly improved sensorial and calculative
abilities have changed the character of the
meaty material and the specialised brain
cells - the actual software or to quote the
current in term - the wetware does not exist
as such.
Software and wetware exists as a series of
electrons arranged in a certain way, just
as the metal hard disc is electronically
arranged in a different way (as a connected
series of metal discs.) To a computer programmer
or a specialist there is nothing complicated
about the fact that a computer can provide
a condition report whenever the operator
requires one.
I have such an datergicware object of systematised
matter on my PC which alerts me if the computational
material, ( i. e. the computer) is overheating.
That does not mean that either the information
exists nor the condition exists - it just
means that the computer exists in that physical
manner at the moment it was instructed by
me to give the systems report (an arrangement
of datergy on my screen) and that I modify
the way I exist by becoming informed as to
the temperature of the computer.
Thus when a human body provides a systems alert (referred to by the Platonist philosopher
as qualia (Latin for what sort or what kind,) or report in the form of electro-chemical
signals from the eardrum or he damaged toe
- it is the tintinnabulating eardrum and
the stubbed toe that exists not some primitive
dualism called
tintinnabulation or pain.
The human brain does not provide its feed
back in the form of a readable script on
a monitor screen, because developmentally
and ergonomically a meaty monitor screen
attached to the human head would have provided
a clumsy encumbrance - specially when walking
about in low-ceilinged caves. The painful
toe alerts the CNS electronically via nerve
fibres, and the read out is managed by the
regrouping and re-chunking of the synaptic
openings and closures within the network
(the rapid colour changes of a squid provides
a useful analogy) which provides patterned
cellular configurations that symbolise the
ringing ears or the damaged toe.
Nature is very simple. But for people who
believe in spirits, ghosts, disembodied mindsconsciousness and the rest of the compendium of foolishness,
it is in their interest to make the processing
human brain appear as mysterious as they
possible can. A general realization amongst
the public that these dualisms are merely
the result of ignorance would throw immediate
suspicion on the claims of religion and its
souls and spirits and the rest of the mumbo
jumbo.
The ontologically confusing and misleading
terms Hardware and Software are defunct, useless, out of date terms
which give completely erroneous impressions
of what constitutes a computer or a human
brain.
When a computer programmer introduces a datergic
programme or the human brain receives some
internal or external sensergy that interacts
with the physical existing matergic CD-disc
or the brain meat - the datergy/sensergy is converted into datergic electrical pulses
(the bit stream) by reflections of the matergic
laser beam from a photoelectric cell via
the systematised (suitably arranged) matergic
material we call the datergic operating system. What he installs is merely another form
of electronic datergicware (currently called
software.)
In other words the whole computational operation
is a physical one using combinations of purely
material components - there is nothing metaphysical
involved at all.
The so-called software is usually provided in the form of a physical
CD, or datergy-stick or (or now less usually)
a floppy disc, and is composed of micro matergic
objects we call electrons, (force fields
if you prefer) which cause the matergicware
and the datergicware to interact and cause
the physical computer to exist differently.
But that does not mean that either the action
of the original hardware or the causal action
of the datergicware exists - it simply means that the metal pieces
of the hardware and the electronic pieces
of the application datergicware includes
programs that do real work for users. For
example, word processors, spreadsheets, and
database management systems fall under the
category of application datergicware.
But it is the physical personal processor
and the physical processing brain and the
physical datergy which is processed and can
be found in the world - not the processing.
|