The Greeks and Greek Civilization
Jacob Christoph Burckhard
What did the Ancient Greeks look like? What
were their attitudes towards Physical Beauty?
Excerpt below from pages 127-9 of his great
book
The Greeks and Greek Civilization
Translated by S. G. C. Middlemore, 1878
Read the full text of his famous
The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy
in The Athenaeum Library of Philosophy
HERE:
|
Jacob Christoph Burckhard was born as the
son of a pastor in Basel 25.5.1818 in Basel;
and died 8.8.1897. His family was one of
the most distinguished in the city - eleven
ancestors had served its Bürgermeister. Also
the family of Burckhardt's mother, Susanne
Maria (née Schorendorf), had lived in Basel
for generations. Following the wishes of
his father, in 1836 Burckhardt started to
study theology the University of Basel. After
becoming under the influence of the German
theologian and biblical critic, W. M. L.
de Wette, Burckhardt abandoned his theological
studies, and entered University of Berlin
in the early 1840s. He studied history and
the history of art under Leopold von Ranke
(1795-1886), whose methods of historical
study he adopted. Before publishing his first
major work, DIE ZEIT CONSTANTINS DES GROSSEN (1853), Burckhardt revised and edited the
Handbuch der Geschichte der Malerei (1847)
and the Handbuch der Kunstgeschichte by his
teacher Franz Kugler (1848).
|
The Greeks and Greek Civilization'
What did the Ancient Greeks look like? What
were their attitudes towards Physical Beauty?
Excerpt below from pages 127-9 Translated
by S. G. C. Middlemore, 1878
What did the ancient Greeks look like? What
were their attitudes towards physical beauty?
"We might expect that it would be representational
art that would tell us most about the physique
of the Greeks. But this hope can be only
partly fulfilled; art does not show an average,
but the exceptional, selected and arranged
on ideal principles; it is proof only of
what was considered admirable and splendid,
and of how people would have liked to look.
Even so, art provides strong evidence that
the Greeks were beautiful. A nation of ugly
people would not have been able to produce
this beauty merely by longing for it, and
what passed for beauty must often have been
seen in reality. Apart from the grave-finds,
which will help to establish a norm of skeletal
structure, we must rely chiefly on literary
testimony, and since the Greeks' opinion
of their own beauty can hardly count as evidence,
we are forced to wait for outsiders to give
their views. A document of this kind does
exist, though it is of late date (the beginning
of the fifth century A. D.); it is an important
passage of the Physiognomica of Adamantius
Judaeus and was discovered by 0. Muller.
Here a baptized Jew is speaking of the Hellenes
as a race already considered remarkable.
Apart from some general observations he says
they were 'just sufficiently (autarkos) tall,
sturdy, pale-complexioned, with well- formed
hands and feet, a medium-sized head, strong
neck, fine brown softly-waving hair, square-faced
(prosopon tetragonon), that is not oval but
with fairly strong cheekbones), the lips
delicate, the nose straight, the eyes lustrous
and expressive, (opthalmous hugrous, charpous,
gorgous): they have the most beautiful eyes
of any people in the world'
This very interesting statement is the only
one of its kind; all others only provide
partial information. Either they report that
within the nation certain tribes, the lonians
for instance, were considered specially hand-some,
or they list elements of beauty, that is
the individual features of an ideal canon,
and those as exceptional, not as average
and typical, or else they relate these elements
to changes in time, noting a decline in beauty,
as for instance when Cicero observes that
when he stayed in Athens there were hardly
any beautiful youths there. Aristotle's views
on beauty are important. In a quite unexpected
place, the Politics(5.7) he asserts, with
the same logic he applies to the state, that
various types are equally valid: for the
nose, as well as the most beautiful straight
shape, one somewhat incurving, and the eagle
type, can also be beautiful, if the divergence
is not too pronounced. In his opinion beauty
is also in part acquired, so that one can
speak of a double beauty, in that, for instance,
the competitors at the pentathlon are built
for speed as well as strength; and beauty
differs from one time of life to another
- the old man may possess it as well as the
youth and the man in his prime. Obviously,
independent of theory, beauty has always
been admired in a variety of forms.
Not only were the Greeks most strongly affected
by beauty, but they universally and frankly
expressed their conviction of its value,
in sharp contrast to the moderns, who do
their best to see it from the ethical viewpoint
as a very fragile gift. In the first place
no shyness hindered people from openly praying
for beauty. An example is the Spartan child,
later the wife of Demaratus, who because
of her ugliness was daily carried by her
nurse to the temple of Helen at Therapne;
there the nurse stood before the statue of
the most beautiful of women and implored
that the child's ugliness might be taken
away. One day a female figure appeared, stroked
the child's head and promised that she should
be the most beautiful of all Spartan women,
and she at once became so. It was also possible
for beauty to be rewarded with semi-divine
honours after death; indeed beauty in itself
made enemies think of a man as a demigod,
and to believe that they should do penance
for having killed him. Thus the Segestans
(who were only half Greek) built a heroon
and brought offerings to Philip of Croton,
an Olympic victor and the finest-looking
Hellene of his time, after he fell in battle
fighting them and the Carthaginians (about
510). Or it might happen that a warrior charging
down on the enemy in all his youthful beauty
would be spared because they recognized something
superhuman in him. In such cases national
prejudice was set aside, as we learn from
the fact that the Persian general Masistius,
killed in skirmishing before the battle of
Plataea, was carried about the field because
all the Greeks wanted to see his beautiful
corpse. Even Xerxes himself was acknowledged
by reason of his beauty as worthiest among
all his myriads of men to be the leader.
To our own thinking it is particularly striking
that a person can praise his own beauty without
diffidence; in Xenophon's Symposium (4.10
f.) Critobulus says plainly and in detail
how much value he places on it, and adds
that he would not exchange it for the power
of the Persian king. The first wish made
for sons who are to rule is that their appearance
should match their destiny; the essential
is that physique should have its own claim
to high rank."
|